• SubScribe commentary
  • The schedule
    • Celebrities >
      • Robin Williams and suicide reporting
      • George Clooney v Daily Mail, round 3
      • Are we playing fair with celebrities?
      • L'Wren Scott's death and Mick Jagger's grief
      • Jill Dando
      • Alain de Botton and Philip Seymour Hoffman
      • Wendi Deng and Rebekah Wade love letters
      • Elizabeth Hurley
      • Gwyneth Paltrow
      • William Roache
    • Crime >
      • The release of Harry Roberts
      • Alan Henning and Alice Gross
      • Dave Lee Travis and Operation Yewtree
      • Rotherham child sex exploitation
      • Operation Tuleta
      • Rolf Harris and Andy Coulson sentencing
      • Maxine Carr's wedding
      • Ann Maguire stabbing
      • Stephen Lawrence and police corruption: time to sit up and take notice
      • The Mirror and Jill Dando
      • William Roache acquitted
      • Rape cases never have a happy ending
      • Lee Rigby and the law of contempt
      • Michael Le Vell: don't shoot the messenger
      • Madeleine McCann: missing an opportunity
      • Maria the 'Greek Madeleine'
    • Foreign Affairs >
      • David Haines and Isis propaganda
      • The murder of Steven Sotloff
      • James Foley murdered
      • Nigeria's abducted girls and massacre
      • Kidnapped Nigerian schoolgirls
      • Al Jazeera on trial: why should we care about journalists?
      • Al Jazeera on trial: the final session
      • Al Jazeera on trial: Abdullah Elshamy
      • Al Jazeera on trial: Peter Greste
      • Al Jazeera on trial: the court hearings
      • Peter Greste sent back to jail as Al-Jazeera journalists' trial is adjourned
      • Al-Jazeera journalists refused bail in Egypt
      • Frontline reporting
      • Putin, the Man of Destiny, and dreams of a Eurasian empire
      • Putin wants more than Crimea, he wants half of Ukraine
      • Ukraine revolution and the threat to the West
      • Obama's selfie
      • Typhoon Haiyan
    • Gender Issues >
      • It takes all sorts to make a family
      • This is what a flawed feminist campaign looks like
      • A level results day: bring on the token boys
      • Kellie Maloney faces the world
      • Cheerleading
      • Pregnant soldiers
      • Women in trouble for getting ahead
      • Doris Lessing, Helen Mirren and silly sexist tokenism
      • Bank notes campaign
    • Health and Beauty >
      • Ebola
      • Ashya King and the force of authority
      • Robin Williams and suicide reporting
      • Sun boobs with page 3 breast cancer campaign
      • Stephen's story: did the Press help his cause or take over his life?
      • Anorexia, bulimia and high-achieving students
      • Colchester cancer scandal
      • New year diets
      • Food for thought: will red meat kill you?
    • Obituary >
      • Robin Williams and suicide reporting
      • Chapman Pincher
      • Rik Mayall and the trouble with death
      • Tony Benn: why we shouldn't speak ill of the dead
      • Thatcher and Crow: speaking ill of the dead
      • Bob Crow wins last media battle
      • Fred Sanger
      • Nelson Mandela
      • Doris Lessing
    • Politics >
      • Poppymania
      • Cameron's tax cut promise
      • Brooks Newmark sting
      • Scottish referendum >
        • Scottish referendum: the final editions
        • Scottish referendum miscellany
        • The Queen speaks
      • Politicians need their holidays too
      • Cameron's reshuffle: bring on the women
      • Food banks
      • The European elections audit >
        • Election audit: the last wordle
        • Election audit: Daily Mail
        • Election audit: The Times
        • Election audit: Daily Express
        • Election audit: Daily Mirror
        • Election audit: The Independent
        • Election audit: Guardian
        • Election audit: Daily Telegraph
        • Election audit: The Sun
      • Maria Miller
      • The blue-rinse bingo Budget
      • Harman, Hewitt and the paedophiles
      • Hewitt apologises and the Sun picks up the cudgels
      • Mail v Labour trio, day 6: Harman capitulates and the bully wins
      • David Miranda detention matters to us all
      • Education >
        • A level results day: bring on the token boys
      • Immigration >
        • A year of xenophobia
        • The Express and immigration
      • The Royal Family >
        • Prince Charles and the floods
        • Prince George
      • Sport >
        • Cheerleading
        • Kelly Gallagher beats the world
        • Why is football more important than all the news?
        • Jenny Jones struggles against Kate and ManU
      • The weather >
        • Smog
  • Journalists in court
  • Phone hacking
  • The Brooks-Coulson trial
    • Hacking trial: sentences
    • Hacking trial: commentary
    • Hacking trial: background
    • Hacking trial: reportage and comment
    • Hacking trial: press coverage
    • Hacking trial: verdict and reaction
    • Hacking trial: sentencing hearing
    • Hacking trial: mitigation
    • Hacking trial: Rebekah speaks
    • Hacking trial: mainstream Press
    • Hacking trial: periodicals
    • Hacking trial: Guardian
    • Hacking trial: Independent
    • Hacking trial: The Times
    • Hacking trial: Daily Telegraph
    • Hacking trial: The whitetops
    • Hacking trial: The redtops
    • Hacking trial: evidence
  • Nationals
    • Express
    • Guardian
    • Independent
    • The i
    • Mail
    • Mirror
    • Daily Star
    • Sun
    • Telegraph
    • Times
  • OpEd
    • OpEd: UK politics 24-12-14
    • OpEd: 23-12-14 Christmas
    • OpEd: 22-12-14 UK politics
    • OpEd: 19-12-14 North Korea
    • OpEd: 18-12-14 British politics
    • OpEd: 17-12-14 UK politics
    • OpEd: 16-12-14 UK politics
    • OpEd: CIA torture 15-12-14
    • OpEd: UK politics 12-12-14
    • OpEd: CIA torture 11-12-14
    • OpEd: CIA torture 10-12-14
    • OpEd: British politics 09-12-14
    • OpEd: British politics 08-12-14
    • OpEd: Autumn Statement 05-12-14
    • OpEd: Autumn Statement 04-12-14
    • OpEd: Autumn Statement 03-12-14
    • OpEd: Gordon Brown 02-12-14
    • OpEd: Black Friday 01-12-14
    • OpEd: Scottish finance 28-11-14
    • OpEd: European politics 27-11-14
    • OpEd: David Mellor 26-11-14
    • OpEd: Lewis Hamilton 25-11-14
    • OpEd: British politics 24-11-14
    • OpEd: British politics 21-11-14
    • OpEd: British politics 20-11-14
    • OpEd: British politics 19-11-14
    • OpEd: British politics 18-11-14
    • OpEd: British politics 17-11-14
    • OpEd: Labour 14-11-14
    • OpEd: forex scandal 13-11-14
    • OpEd: British politics 12-11-14
    • OpEd: the Labour Party 11-11-14
    • OpEd: Ed Miliband 10-11-14
    • OpEd: British politics 07-11-14
    • OpEd: British politics 06-11-14
    • OpEd: British politics 05-11-14
    • OpEd: British politics 04-11-14
    • OpEd: space tourism 03-11-14
    • OpEd: British politics 31-10-14
    • OpEd: immigration 30-10-14
    • OpEd: immigration 29-10-14
    • OpEd: British politics 28-10-14
    • OpEd: British politics 27-10-14
    • OpEd: NHS 24-10-14
    • OpEd: British politics 23-10-14
    • OpEd: Ukip 22-10-14
    • OpEd: Britain and EU 21-10-14
    • OpEd: British politics 20-10-14
    • OpEd: Lord Freud 17-10-14
    • OpEd: British politics 16-10-14
    • OpEd: British politics 15-10-14
    • OpEd: British politics 14-10-14
    • OpEd: British politics 13-10-14
    • OpEd: Isis and UK politics 10-10-14
    • OpEd: British politics 09-10-14
    • OpEd: British politics 08-09-14
    • OpEd: LibDem conference 07-10-14
    • OpEd: British politics 06-10-14
    • OpEd: party conferences 03-10-14
    • OpEd: Cameron's speech 02-10-14
    • OpEd: Conservative conference 01-10-14
    • OpEd: Conservative conference 30-09-14
    • OpEd: Conservative conference 29-09-14
    • OpEd: War on Isis 26-09-14
    • OpEd: Labour conference 25-09-14
    • OpEd: Miliband's speech 24-09-14
    • OpEd: Labour conference 23-09-14
    • OpEd: Referendum fallout 22-09-14
    • OpEd: Scottish referendum 19-09-14
    • OpEd: Scottish referendum 18-09-14
    • OpEd: Scottish referendum 17-09-14
    • OpEd: Scottish referendum 16-09-14
    • OpEd: Scottish referendum 15-09-14
    • OpEd: Scottish referendum 12-09-14
    • OpEd: Scottish referendum 11-09-14
    • OpEd: Scottish referendum 10-09-14
    • OpEd: Scottish referendum 09-09-14
    • OpEd: Scottish referendum 08-09-14
    • OpEd: Scottish referendum 05-09-14
    • OpEd: Nato and Isis threat 04-09-14
    • OpEd: Scottish independence 03-09-14
    • OpEd: Nude photographs 02-09-14
    • OpEd: British politics 01-09-14
    • OpEd: Ukip defection 29-08-14
    • OpEd: Rotherham sex abuse 28-08-14
    • OpEd: Islamic militants 27-08-14
    • OpEd: Middle East 26-08-14
    • OpEd: James Foley 22-08-14
    • OpEd: James Foley 21-08-14
    • OpEd: British politics 20-08-14
    • OpEd: Iraq 19-08-14
    • OpEd: Iraq 18-08-14
    • OpEd: A levels 15-08-14
    • OpEd: Iraq 14-08-14
    • OpEd: Robin Williams 13-08-14
    • OpEdL Iraq 12-08-14
    • OpEd: Iraq 11-08-14
    • OpEd: Boris Johnson 08-08-14
    • OpEd: Boris Johnson 07-08-14
    • OpEd: Warsi resignation 06-08-14
    • OpEd: First World War centenary 05-08-14
    • OpEd: Gaza 04-08-14
    • OpEd: British politics 01-08-14
    • OpEd: Gaza 31-07-14
    • OpEd: British politics 30-07-14
    • OpEd: British politics 29-07-14
    • OpEd: Gaza 28-07-14
    • OpEd: Gaza 25-07-14
    • OpEd: EU and Russia 24-07-14
    • OpEd: Flight MH17 23-07-14
    • OpEd: Flight MH17 22-07-14
    • OpEd: Flight MH17 21-07-14
    • oped: Gaza 18-07-14
    • OpEd: Cameron's reshuffle 17-07-14
    • OpEd: Cameron's reshuffle 16-07-14
    • OpEd: Cameron's reshuffle 15-07-14
    • OpEd: British politics 14-07-2014
    • OpEd: public sector strikes 11-07-14
    • OpEd: public sector strikes 10-07-14
    • OpEd: sex abuse 09-07-14
    • OpEd Sex abuse 08-07-14
    • OpEd: Westminster child abuse 07-07-2014
    • OpEd: Middle East 04-07-14
    • OpEd: Ed Miliband 03-07-14
    • OpEd British politics: 02-07-14
    • OpEd: edeucation 01-07-14
    • OpEd: Britain and Europe 30-06-14
    • OpEd: Britain and Europe 27-06-14
    • OpEd: Luis Suárez 26-06-14
    • OpEd: Iraq 25-06-14
    • OpEd: British politics 24-06-14
    • OpEd: Iraq 23-06-14
    • OpEd: Iraq 20-06-14
    • OpEd: British politics, 19-06-14
    • OpEd: British politics, 18-06-2014
    • OpEd: Iraq 17-06-14
    • OpEd: Tony Blair 16-06-14
    • OpEd: Iraq 13-06-14
    • OpEd: Oxfam, baby buggies, World Cup 12-06-14
    • OpEd: education and British values 11-06-14
    • OpEd: extremist education 10-06-14
    • OpEd: May v Gove 09-06-14
  • The columnists
  • Regionals
    • Regional Press Awards 2013
    • Local newspaper week
    • Local papers matter
    • Reading Chronicle and football hooliganism
    • Time for change
    • Monty's vision
    • The Full Monty: the Local World vision put into practice
    • The Pirates of Parkham
    • Colchester cancer scandal
  • Backnumbers
    • Weekend papers Dec 27-28
    • Front pages Dec 22-26, 2014
    • Weekend papers Dec 20-21
    • Front pages Dec 15-19
    • Weekend front pages Dec 13-14
    • Front pages Dec 8-12
    • Weekend papers Dec 6-7
    • Front pages Dec 1-5
    • Weekend papers Nov 29-30
    • Front pages Nov 24-28
    • Weekend papers Nov 22-23
    • Front pages Nov 17-21
    • Weekend papers Nov 15-16
    • Front pages Nov 10-14
    • Weekend papers Nov 8-9
    • Front pages Nov 3-7
    • Weekend papers Nov 1-2
    • Front pages Oct 27-31
    • Weekend papers Oct 25-26, 2014
    • Front pages Oct 20-24
    • Weekend papers Oct 18-19, 2014
    • Front pages Oct 12-17
    • Front pages Oct 5-11
    • Front pages Sept 28-Oct 4
    • front pages Sept 21-27
    • Front pages Sept 14-20
    • front pages Sept 7-13 2014
    • front pages Aug 31-Sep 6
    • Front pages Aug 24-30, 2014
    • Front pages August 17-23, 2014
    • Front pages, Aug 10-16, 2014
    • Front pages, Aug 3-9, 2014
    • Front pages July 27-August2, 2014
    • Front pages July 20-26, 2014
    • front pages July 13-19, 2014
    • Front pages: July 6-12, 2014
    • Front pages June 29-July 5, 2014
    • Front pages June 22-28, 2014
    • Front pages June 15-21
    • Front pages June 8-14, 2014
    • Front pages June 1-7, 2014
    • Nationals May 25-31
    • Front pages May 18-24 >
      • Press review: 24-05-14
      • Press review: 21-05-14
      • Press review: 20-05-14
    • Front pages May 11-17 >
      • Press review 15-05-14
      • Press review 14-05-14
      • Press review 13-05-14
      • Press review 12-05-14
    • front pages May 4-10, 2014 >
      • The review 09-05-14
      • The review 08-05-2014
      • The review 07-05-14
    • Front pages April 27-May 3 2014
    • Front pages April 20-26, 2014
    • Front pages April 13-19
    • Front pages April 6-12, 2014
    • The front pages March 30-April 5
    • The front pages March 23-29, 2014
    • front pages march 16-22
    • front pages March 9-15, 2014
    • front pages March 2-8, 2014
    • front pages Feb 23-Mar 1 2014
    • front pages Feb 16-22, 2014
    • The front pages Feb 9-15 2014
    • The front pages Feb 3-8, 2014
    • The front pages January 2014
  • You have to laugh
  • Blog archive
  • About SubScribe
  • Join the SubScribers
  • Contact us
  • Cookie policy


European elections: the SubScribe audit

Nigel Farage
'The media were to blame... They gave Farage too much publicity... His face was everywhere... Why is the party getting so much coverage? ..Why is he always on Question Time? ..It isn't four-party politics... Labour WON.'

The close focus on Ukip after the council election results were declared irritated a lot of people, particularly those on the Left. Labour had the biggest share of the vote and took the most council seats. Ukip's performance, as projected nationally by the BBC, had been worse than last year. It had 17% of the vote, compared with 23% in 2013.
Labour has twice as many new councillors as Ukip and took control of six authorities; Ukip holds the balance of power in some councils and has become the official opposition in others, but it has none under its control.
Based on these figures, without interpretation, the complaints seemed fair. But political journalism is all about interpretation.  Bald figures can be deceptive. 
Look at the result of the first ballot in the Conservative leadership election of 1990. Margaret Thatcher secured 204 of the 273 available votes, a 54.8% share of the vote and a 14% majority over Michael Heseltine. By any measure, she had won. But she had lost, and it was so apparent that she had lost that she was persuaded not to contest the next round.

A year before a general election, an opposition party should be sprinting ahead. Labour under Ed Miliband is jogging - and there's a fourth competitor on the three-lane track jostling for position, pushing any and all of the other competitors out of the way to try to get a clear run. 
As a far-Right party,  Ukip was expected to take votes from the Tories - but it surprised people by the extent to which it robbed Labour as well.
These were the news elements of the story - the match report, as opposed to the classified results - because news is what is different or unexpected, and the opposition party doing well in an election is not unusual.
Come Sunday and the announcement of the European results, the importance of the rise of the Right across the continent was undeniable. Ukip topped the polls all over Britain - with the exception of the North West - and took the largest share of the national vote . The Liberal Democrats were slaughtered.
Was this surge the result, if only in part, of media coverage of the election campaigns? The BBC - and Nick Robinson - has come in for much criticism from all quarters, with Nigel Farage's frequent appearances on Question Time cited as evidence.
[SubScribe is about the Press rather than broadcasting, but will be looking at this later this week. For now, we'll just point out that the Greens' leader Natalie Bennett appeared twice before last year's elections; this time her party was represented only once - by the MP Caroline Lucas. Unlike Ukip, the Greens have an MP. They also pushed the LibDems into fourth place.]
As to the newspapers - or at least the news pages -  they barely woke up to Ukip until it shocked everyone by coming top of an opinion poll last month. Before that, it was Nick Clegg who read the runes. On February 11 he wrote a column for the i in which he said:
Picture
"Ukip has been coming up on the rails in British politics for years and it sees this May as its breakthrough moment. Mainstream politicians have made the mistake in the past of not taking UKIP, or the people who say they will vote for it, seriously. That time has long passed. Ukip is for real. But if it were to win this May and take Britain a further step towards self- imposed exile from Europe, it could wreck the recovery and destroy British jobs."
And it was Clegg who challenged Farage to a televised debate on Europe - only to be bested on both outings. It wasn't unbalanced reporting that gave Ukip the limelight, it was the LibDem leader - who is now nursing his wounds.
Press coverage of Ukip was mostly hostile, even the Express balked at backing the party. The Times  splashed on three different "scandals" - the first questioned the way party funds were used, the second challenged Farage's expenses and the third looked at allegations that candidates were expected to pay a £10,000 dowry if they got into Strasbourg.
Times 8 March
March 8
Times April 15
April 15
Times May 15
May 15
Guardian poll 15-04
On the day the Times was reporting on Farage's expenses, the Guardian carried a post-Budget opinion poll under the heading "Tories stumble..." Labour was five points ahead on general election voting intentions and eleven in front for the European elections.
Ukip were on the up for the general election and holding steady at 20% for Europe.

The following week Farage unveiled a series of billboards that were to be the central plank of his party's advertising campaign. They brought howls of protest - and a rash of spoofs.
Ukip poster
ukip poster
moyes spoof poster
ukip spoof poster
ukip spoof poster
Farage pronounced himself delighted with the posters, saying "I wish we'd gone further."
By now commentators were treating Ukip with greater seriousness. It could no longer be written off as a bunch of fruitcakes and loonies - racist fruitcakes and loonies at that - because the advance in the polls was relentless. By the end of the week YouGov had the party overtaking Labour to come out top in voting intentions for the European elections. But more than half of those polled - including a fifth of Ukip supporters - thought it had unworkable policies or that it was incapable of running the country.
Guardian 26-04
Sindie 27-04-14
The sight of Ukip at the top of the opinion polls was a jolt and Decca Aitkenhead's interview for the Guardian made the paper's Saturday splash. There had been much mumbling in the comment pages for months - years, even - but this was the first time any newspaper had focused on the Farage phenomenon as a front-page news story. 
The Independent was having the same thoughts and the following day the Sindie came up with the striking front page below  left.
A week later the Sunday Times splashed on Cameron declaring that he was "ready" for Farage, but even now, three weeks before polling day, there was little appetite for the European elections - and none at all for the locals.
All  eyes were on the big prize next year - although there was also a growing awareness that the Scottish referendum was creeping closer and that there was no certainty that Salmond would lose and the Union survive.
There had been plenty of politics all year, but these were personality rather than policy stories. On the Tories' side there was the Nigel Evans trial, MPs resigning over rent boys and their cleaners, allegations of sex parties at the annual conference, the ousting of Maria Miller, should Boris run for Parliament? And Plebgate just wouldn't go away. 
The LibDems were also embroiled in sex scandals with the Lord Rennard and Mike Hancock controversies - as well as having the Mail on their case over Cyril Smith, accusing the party of turning a blind eye to his abuse of children. 
With all this going on, there was little time for Miliband and co, although there was a flutter of interest when he brought David Axelrod over from America to offer election advice. 
The Labour leader talked about nationalisation and the minimum wage; Michael Gove talked about everything from FGM to American novelists; only Clegg talked about Europe - but no one (other than Farage on TV) was talking to him.

It was as though the prospect of "Polling station" signs coming out of storage  - and an extra 19 days' leave from Westminster  because there wasn't anything to do there - had given the politicos a licence to wander around the country posing for silly pictures and talking about anything they fancied, regardless of whether it was relevant to the coming election. 
Should the Press have pulled them back on course and questioned them about the common agricultural policy or the working hours directive, trade or energy policy? Would anyone have printed or read the answers? Much simpler to follow the key players around and report what they said - especially if they hadn't a clue how much they spent on tins of tuna in Waitrose of a Saturday or who was leader of Middlewallop council.
There was, of course, one subject with which the Press had an endless fascination; the subject that had dominated the papers at the end of last year before restrictions on Romanians and Bulgarians entering Britain were relaxed.
Immigration policy was worrying a lot of people -  not only little Englanders and racists -  nd it was something that might perhaps be influenced by whoever was elected to Strasbourg . And so it came to  dominate the campaign.  It was a gift to Farage, and the Express and Mail seemed only too willing to help. 
Neither newspaper would go so far as to back Ukip, of course, but they were both happy to use the party's focus on immigration to push their own views on the subject. It became a vicious or virtuous circle, depending on your political stance. (See the front pages on the right.)
The splash head on Decca Aitkenhead's Farage interview last month described him as a man with no MPs and only one policy. But at least most people understood what that policy was. 
Not one newspaper published the parties' manifestos, if indeed such things existed; not even a little pocket guide to the central battlegrounds or key policies. It was as though everyone was expected to vote tribally and to know what their camp stood for.
Coverage of the final  two weeks was utterly without substance:  Miliband making a hash of eating a bacon sandwich;  Boris and Dave making a hash of looking relaxed with their coffees on Newark station (and at the same time showing where the Tories' priorities lay - with the June by-election rather than the imminent vote). 

Campaign stories were almost all based on opinion polls or talking heads hypothesising. Neither politicians nor reporters seemed to have anything to say that might enlighten the electorate or help them to decide which way to vote. We know, for example, that Ukip MEPs are not renowned for their attendance record at Strasbourg; it might have been nice to have been told whether the party's candidates intended to turn up or just take the money and stay at home. The Greens were ignored.

There were moments of truth, such as when Farage was royally tripped up by James O'Brien in an LBC interview, below,  but they were rare. No wonder turnout was so low.

Picture
Picture
The audit
Picture
SubScribe is looking through the election coverage of national papers, apart from the FT,  Star and i, from May 12-26 
The details
Daily Telegraph
The Guardian
Independent
Daily Mirror
Daily Express
Daily Mail
The Times
The Sun

The whitetop
agenda
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
SubScribe logo
UK border




Opening our borders

Let's stop the scare stories and start printing 
some facts

Picture
Worried about jobs, benefits, crime? Look no further than our newspapers. Read more on
A year of xenophobia


Editor's pick
Maxine Carr
Why we should celebrate Maxine Carr's dream wedding
Michael LeVell
Whatever the verdict, rape cases never have a happy ending -  for the accused or
his accuser
bring back our girls
Nearly 300 girls are kidnapped and we barely turn a hair. How Twitter put the Press to shame
Croydon house
A young man kills himself because he can't find a job, another worries about not being able to buy a £600,000 house
Paul McCartney
We know who he is, so please stop telling us that McCartney was once one
of the Beatles
Stephen Sutton
Stephen's story:
did the Press help his cause or take over the end of his life?
pom pom dancer
Do you know what these women are doing? It's probably not what you think
Milly Dowler
Moving on from Milly to Moses: let's give the new Press regulator
a chance

comments powered by Disqus

Please sign up for SubScribe updates  
(no spam, no more than one every week or two)

I'd like to become a SubScriber

* indicates required
Quick links

Picture
Main sections:
The industry
Press freedom
Press regulation
The schedule
Phone hacking
News judgment
Regionals
Picture
About SubScribe
Send an email
Blogs:
Pictures and spreads
Editor's blog
Press Box
Style Counsel
You have to laugh
OpEd
Front page reviews
Picture
The old blog